Best Coffee in Bay Shore

Bay Shore, a vibrant coastal suburb on Long Island's South Shore, boasts a bustling Main Street, historic landmarks, and a lively waterfront, reflecting its rich maritime heritage.

Suburb•New York, United States•Population: 29,244

Good Coffee in Bay Shore

Looking for the perfect cup of coffee in Bay Shore? We've curated a list of the best coffee shops that locals and visitors love. From expertly crafted espresso to cozy atmospheres, these top-rated cafes offer exceptional coffee experiences.

Milano Bean Cafe

#1

If you're wandering through Bay Shore and in search of a cozy spot to unwind, Milano Bean Cafe is your ideal destination. Known for its inviting 'town hall' vibe, this cafe is a haven for those who appreciate a good latte and a welcoming atmosphere. Despite some critiques regarding their pastry prices and black coffee, the cafe's ambiance and personable ownership make it a place where you feel like part of the family. Though it's no longer dog-friendly, the comfortable seating and friendly baristas continue to make it a beloved spot for locals.

6 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706, USA