Best Coffee in Islip

My Town's Café shines in East Islip with its homey atmosphere and exceptional coffee offerings. Owned by a sweet couple, this cozy spot is not just about the rich and smooth coffee but also the warm, inviting ambiance that makes every visitor feel at home. With rave reviews for its Harvest Roll macchiato and delectable pastries, this café is a haven for those who appreciate a perfect blend of flavor and community spirit. It's a must-visit spot for anyone seeking a comforting coffee experience.

Nestled within the Bayard Cutting Arboretum, The Hidden Oak Café offers a unique experience with its charming ambiance and delightful tea service. The café's enchanting setting, complete with park and water views, provides a serene backdrop for enjoying a cup of coffee or a light meal. While the sandwiches may vary in flavor, the overall experience is elevated by the picturesque surroundings and friendly service. It's a delightful stop for those exploring the arboretum and looking to unwind with a warm beverage.

Hometown Cafe is a staple in East Islip, known for its robust coffee and friendly, welcoming atmosphere. Despite some mixed reviews, regulars appreciate the cozy setting complete with a fireplace and the feeling of familiarity as the staff often greets customers by name. The café serves a classic breakfast and lunch menu, making it a reliable spot for those seeking comfort food paired with a good cup of coffee. It's a place where locals gather to enjoy hearty meals and warm service.